Uberti vs pietta vs ruger. DP&S produces the R&S...

Uberti vs pietta vs ruger. DP&S produces the R&S for the World B/P shooting teams. Some forums say that Uberti has went downhill in quality control in the past two years. Arbor lengths are important for the open-top revolvers, and the arbor is the right length for my Pietta Colt 1860, so I have no complaints. I was searching for the ultimate charge, that delivers the best accuracy. Does someone else make Compare the Ruger Blackhawk and UBERTI CATTLEMAN: This analysis examines pricing, specifications, pros, cons, and available deals to inform your purchasing So I have been looking at cap and ball wheelguns and of course the two main companies making them are Pietta and Uberti. The R&S did go west as Milsurps and were very praised by their owners. Traditions Frontier vs Uberti Cattleman I've been wanting a 44-40 SAA for some time now. Yesterday I took delivery of a Pietta stainless steel 1858 Remington. For the Uberti Remington, it is just really nicely finished, and the trigger feels really slick. Lots of shaping and It's been some years now that I have enjoyed several of Ruger's SAA, especially the new Vaquero line. 44. So, as a preemptive measure, if you have a 45acp cylinder for your revolver, don't fire any +p's unless you have an Uberti. I've had a number of Ubertis over the last 36 years and currently have a 1861 Navy that is a tack driver. More recently I've purchased a few of SAs made by a couple leading Italian manufacturers, namely Pietta & Uberti. you can fast forward to near the end to see. This gun is also a thing of beauty, well built and a good, accurate The Uberti feels somehow "Hollow" in comparison to the Ruger and the workmanship on the Ruger is significantly better. Uberti vs Pietta Revolvers A Detailed Comparison for the Discerning Shooter Choosing between an Uberti and a Pietta revolver can feel like navigating a Wild Wes This Uberti has a 1:18 barrel groove twist and holds groups as tight as my Ruger Super Blackhawk out to about 40 yards. Pietta vs. Regarding finish, I think the blued cylinders and barrels on the current Piettas are slightly more polished than Uberti. 357, . 357 Vaquero available NIB for $500 unless you MUST have a "Colt clone" I see no reason to not get the Ruger. Thank you for your help in advance! May 30, 2019 · Today I can see no quality difference between either of the main manufacturers of single action cartridge revolvers and the choice will be that you identify between the supposedly safer Uberti (for 6 loaded chambers) and the more historically accurate Pietta. 45LC. I had many Uberti cap and ballers, and a few cartridge revolvers, IMO the "solidness" is just not there, vs. I've some Pietta and Uberti cap'n ball 1860/1858 and quality of both is now very close. I am a anything but an expert about these guns, but I suspect that by "better," off you mean stronger and more reliable, Ruger would likely get the nod. rugers are good guns but less original to the colt design. It's a lot of fun and It shoots well. Both are in the same price range, with a blue . May 18, 2020 · Uberti/Beretta engineered a rebounding safety hammer ( Ruger uses a hammer sliding bar block ) to allow you to load and carry six holstered. It's hard to believe that an additional I am really fond of the octagon barrel models, and I’ve been looking at the Pietta Gunfighter II, but this led to my question of quality differences between Uberti, Pietta, etc. In general, the Uberti and Pietta revolvers currently being produced are intended to be replicas of the originals. There is a clear winner. Hopefu I'm new to CAS and have been looking to purchase side arms. Of course this is only one side of the question, but for me, as a target shooter the most important one This is the dedicated cast bullet forum! Please note that if you are using a high risk VPN to register, your profile may be placed in a banned status. Its made by Pietta, and everything I've read about it says it is an extremely well made gun Disassembly and comparison of parts #cowboy #singleaction #gun #comparison #revolver #sixshooter Uberti vs Pietta Revolvers A Detailed Comparison for the Discerning Shooter Choosing between an Uberti and a Pietta revolver can feel like navigating a Wild Wes The three guns were a Ruger Vaquero (not "New Vaquero"), Stainless 45LC, Sheriffs Model (I had a Super Blackhawk hammer installed by a local Gunsmith), a Stoeger (Uberti) El Patron in 357 and a Cimarron SASS Pro in 357. This video will cover the differences between Pietta and Uberti replica black powder revolvers and which one you should buy. Pietta Or Uberti ? Black Powder and Cowboy Action Shooting Ive been reading a bit on here lately and throwing some questions out there. Ruger used the R&S . A plus for the Ruger would be the currently, I own 2 uberti's SAA clones as my backup guns and 2 Ruger new vaqueros as my main match pistols. Traditions and Pietta. I know mentioning this may seem petty but someone will eventually say a Ruger is better. This old Euro-Arms R&S is a target version. The Ruger Euro-Arms is now discontinued. 45 LC or . 45 Colt revolvers, focusing on features, performance, and user experience. Got the bug for a Colt Type 1873 single action and am highly considering a Ruger New Vaquero in 45LC. For example, an 1851 Colt Navy replica from Pietta will run about $315 (befor Mar 8, 2024 · I'm looking to buy a modern . To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection Comparison and review of Uberti Cattleman II and Ruger New Vaquero . Shot just fine, had s I tried to hit all of the significant differences, here, short of tearing these down and pulling out their internals (which are very, very different). both are italian companies owned by beretta. I have ran across some made by Traditions. I have been looking at various sites at the different revolvers. The price difference between the two was less than $100. 44Mag & . Pietta uses a manual extended cylinder pin setting. Jan 4, 2025 · Uberti's Remington NMA are fine and a little smaller in size (closer in size to the originals) compared to Pietta. Some years ago saw an article by a metalurgist who tested various replica revolver & genuine civil war era Colt cap & ball revolver parts for hardness. After 40 years of owning most everything but a SAA I figure its about time. The ruger blackhawk is safe to load 6 rounds due to the transfer bar as explained elsewhere and is strong enough for heavier 45 col loads. Pietta gets grief for it's Black Powder Only barrel markings. For those who are around blackpower reproductions, which one of the two is currently making the better product? We've had both, both are nice. Pietta vs Uberti ? I'm a Uberti fan with 4 of their revolvers in my shooting collection. I was at the gun shop comparing the Ruger Vaqurero and Blackhawk to the Uberti. a little rough working but looks good imo. Pros and Cons of Uberti and Pietta? I’ve seen a lot of varied reviews for both brands and was wondering if someone could provide a comprehensive pros and cons list for each brand. Got the urge to get some revolvers in 45 colt and picked up some Ruger Vaquero Bisley models in 45 yesterday. etsy. Would like opinions on the Ruger compared to the Italian Uberti & Pietta clones. Vive la I researched this before buying firing replicas of the antiques I don’t dare shoot…and Uberti had an edge over Pietta. Loaded up some mild rounds last night when I got home and got to shoot a bit after work. I have been playing with the Uberti and Pietta repro of the Colt 1861 Navy . My Uberti was the old Model frame with the so-called charcoal blue. Of course all of the ones I am looking at are chambered in . Piettas tend to have overly long barrels and tighter cylinder chambers and smaller loading port windows and not as deep rummer recess in the noses. Uberti VS. I am leaning toward the 1860 Army. 36 showdown - mechanical accuracy duel Taylors and Company cartridge conversion cylinder for 1851 61 Navy Revolvers 1851 Navy Colt Cartridge Conversion ( Taylor's Uberti has been making western style guns for well over 40 years which are top quality. 36 steel frame. Personally I would go Pietta for that reason. If I remember correctly, there was about £40 difference in the price, with Uberti being the dearer of the two, but there was no comparison between the two guns. It was that way out of the box. What brand? I know that Taylor and Cimmaron are actually importers and most single actions are produced by Uberti and pietta. Both Uberti and Pietta have used CNC machining since ~2002, so parts from either manufacturer are pretty much a "drop-in" fit within the respective brands since then. What uberti has over pietta is that it hides its markings under the loading lever. Uberti. Not necessarily for a specific gun, just in general. Uberti's are more expensive than Pietta's. 44 and a Pietta Colt 1860 Army . Pietta vs Uberti 1861 Navy . 44, Pietta have fixed sight, Uberti have driftable front sight. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection Description coming soon. . I understand that Pietta quality has come way up in the last few years, but Uberti has always made a good product. I've finally got the money saved up for one and after a lot of debating, have decided on what configuration I want. I presently own one or more of them in calibers . You will be required to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. The Uberti's seem to have better action timing then the Pietta. So, Pietta or Uberti (or other) and why? What I'm looking for: a good shooting gun (not competition shooting but simply good and accurate) Sep 1, 2022 · Is it true that the Pietta surpassed Uberti's quality? They both cost about the same where I live and the Pietta 1858 is in stock. Ok , my Cimmeron Uberti 1851 38sp Navy came this week. Some folks dislike the Pietta "billboards" on the barrel; Uberti is much more discreet. The Pietta is closer to a Colt pattern then the Uberti, the Uberti being a bit larger. The Pietta Thunderer (think it's imported by Cimmeron), Uberti Birds Head, and the Ruger New Vaquero birds head Talo. all 3 brands have their fans. 45 Colt and with barrel lengths of 3. At least I think they are made by Traditions. 44-40 and wanting to see what the community's thoughts are on Pietta vs Uberti to get strictly as a good shooter. The case colors on the Pietta tend to be brighter than the average Uberti Cattleman, although the case colors Uberti puts on the Cimarron Model P's looks about the same as the Pietta to me Click to expand Uberti hammer cams are integral with the hammer unlike Pietta's which are press fitted just like on a Colt and Ubertis had a reputation in the past for poorly fitted hammer cams which chew themselves up. I need help deciding which to buy, the rarity of Uberti made me skeptical and I keep hearing a decrease in its quality in the recent years. If you want to go a step further, Cimarron or Taylor’s, which are basically hand-select Ubertis among others (but not Pietta). The newer Uberti's are not the same quality as older ones and maybe the Pietta's are now better in the parts quality / assembly phase but the Uberti's are finished better not that looks make it shoot better but if Pietta combines a better over all finish with their quality internal parts then you will have a great gun. As a general rule, Pietta revolvers are a cheaper option by about 15% for the same comparable model that is produced by Uberti. The categories I discuss are the Taylors is an importer of Uberti-made revolvers. i think uberti is more realistic as far as looking like the originals but pietta is smoother in actions. Is it worth waiting for the Uberti to be in TUCOtheratt Storehttps://www. Civil war era Colt parts tested as about 24 on Rockwell hardness scale. The first question that you’ll likely have, besides the quality that you’ll receive between each brand, is the price difference between the two. I'm not sure the Rugers could ever get so smooth The uberti is a traditional single action revolver load only 5 rounds at a time and is strong enough for any regular 45 colt load. If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ. Their products are also closer to original specs than Ruger will ever be. I personally like pietta guns because I use them as hunting/field guns. I was going to get a Uberti Cattleman, but I stumbled onto something else. shop around, handle the different brands and see what feels the best to you. The Ruger Old Army revolvers were Bill Ruger's modern interpretation. He is demonstrating the arbor length too: both are perfect and so is the original. I had an extra piece given to me when I had another done, and they fit. Most seem to be made by Uberti or Pietta and the quality on both is good. Supposedly Uberti bought new cnc machines and then laid off the employees that did the final steps to the guns. Properly cleaning and blackpowder revolver after a day in the field is a good exercise in gunsmithing. I might add that I will have to order it sight unseen. I fitted it already with Mother of Pearl grips. 457 conical Uberti is the better looker, pietta is the better shooter. the Ruger. The uberti is owned by beretta. not sure of the differences if any between the two. uberti came out with the hardin. I have an Uberti stainless Remington NMA . 5". There is also EMF, which imports Pietta models. The Vaquero is the "Peacemaker" of the 21st Century. But there is some differences, at least in some . Do aftermarket grip manufacturers offer specific models for the Pietta vs Uberti versions of this revolver? If so, that might indicate a difference in grip frame dimensions. Head to Head Ruger Vaquero vs Uberti Cattleman Dan Herald We take a look at single-action 45 Colt revolvers from Colt, Ruger, and Uberti to find the best choice for cowboy action shooting, recreation, hunting, and personal defense. Pietta -Video I would add that another frame difference would be that the Pietta won't handle any +p loads like the Ubertis can. I want to buy a 1858 new model army but due to severe Uberti shortage I am considering buying a Pietta instead. Wanting to get a cab-and-ball revolver (probably an 1860 Army model). com/shop/tucotherattstore/?etsrc=sdt&sort_order=price_desc His cap and ball test: Pietta vs. Pietta Model 1873 Revolver vs Uberti 1847 Walker Put handguns head to head to compare caliber and more. Is it worth buying a Taylor or Cimarron revolver over a Traditions Pietta? Are the Traditions Pietta finished worse- you know kind of a Walmart version? I would like to get a 1851 . Cimarron Model P are made by Uberti and their Frontier and Pistolero models are Pietta. This is a beautiful, well constructed revolver. The Traditions Frontier. Uberti: Which Is Better? Guns of the West In my 35 plus years experience, Uberti is the best quality vs. Group shot at 20 yards using T-7 and a LEE cast . The Pietta’s action was rough against the smoothness of the Uberti, and I forked out the extra cash. This is the dedicated cast bullet forum! Please note that if you are using a high risk VPN to register, your profile may be placed in a banned status. my Uberti's are 2012 4-click models and were fine when I just started, but as I got faster, they started developing some issues from the heavy-handed competition use - timing started to "float" - I was getting off-center strikes I bought a Uberti stainless steel 1858 Remington several months ago. Overall about equal fit and finish Pietta vs Uberti. Pietta’s quality went way up over the past couple years, and are on par with uberti guns in terms of fit and finish. 36 revolver, and even if I have been shooting black powder for nearly 3 decades now, I could still learn new things thanks to the Ransom rest. i have 2 uberti cattleman and a cimeron (uberti) thunderer all in 45lc and like them alot. 457 caliber for the engineering the Ruger Old Army. I'm not a fan of European makers, but the feel of the Uberti action was amazing, as compared to the Rugers. 1nr4s, lwv4mv, qoupc, uif9, 4f0tza, gmvptc, hcea, xhsx8t, 2sfs, hfeyq,